Stop Hiring Perfect Resumes and Start Looking for People Who Can Learn

Some of the best people you'll ever hire won't check every box on your job description.
And some of the people who check every box won't be nearly as successful as you expected.
That's something I believe organizations need to think about more seriously.
We've become incredibly focused on finding candidates who have already done the exact job we're hiring for.
Same industry. Same software. Same title. Same responsibilities.
And preferably five years of experience using a platform that's only been around for three.
Okay, maybe that's a slight exaggeration.
But you get my point.
When we hire only for what someone has already done, we risk overlooking what they're capable of becoming.
Experience Matters, But So Does Adaptability
I'm not suggesting we ignore qualifications.
Some positions require specific certifications, licenses, technical knowledge, or experience for very good reasons.
You probably don't want someone learning how to operate specialized emergency equipment for the first time during an actual emergency.
But not every position requires an identical career history.
Consider someone who spent years managing people in education and later moved into business operations or sales.
The industries are different.
But are the underlying skills really that different?
Leadership still requires communication, accountability, planning, conflict resolution, and the ability to make decisions.
Managing a budget still requires understanding priorities and allocating limited resources.
Training employees still requires identifying gaps, communicating expectations, and measuring improvement.
Those skills don't disappear because someone changes industries.
The challenge is recognizing them.
Job Descriptions Can Become Wish Lists
Have you ever read a job posting and wondered whether the organization was looking for an employee or an entire department?
The candidate needs leadership experience, technical expertise, project management skills, advanced software knowledge, budgeting experience, marketing ability, and excellent communication skills.
Oh, and they need to be comfortable handling whatever else comes up.
Some positions genuinely require a broad skill set.
But organizations should distinguish between what someone must know on day one and what a capable employee could learn with reasonable training.
That's an important difference.
If a skill can be taught in a few weeks, should it automatically disqualify someone who brings years of relevant leadership experience?
If someone has successfully learned multiple systems, should unfamiliarity with one particular software platform outweigh that history?
We should be asking whether candidates can perform the essential responsibilities and develop the remaining skills within a reasonable timeframe.
Not whether their resume perfectly mirrors the job description.
Look for Evidence of Learning
Here's where I think interviews can become more useful.
Instead of spending the entire conversation asking candidates to repeat their resume, ask them how they've handled unfamiliar situations.
Tell me about a time you had to learn something quickly.
What did you do when your first approach didn't work?
How have you responded when someone challenged your decision?
What skill have you developed recently without being required to?
These questions can reveal qualities that aren't obvious from job titles.
Curiosity. Initiative. Humility. Problem-solving. Persistence.
And perhaps most importantly, the ability to recognize when you don't know something.
I've worked in environments where processes, expectations, and technology changed.
One thing remains consistent: employees who are willing to learn are better positioned to adapt when the work changes.
That doesn't mean every enthusiastic learner is qualified for every role.
It means learning ability deserves a place in the evaluation alongside experience.
The Cost of Overlooking Transferable Skills
Public organizations frequently compete with private employers for talent.
And recruiting can become especially difficult when compensation structures, hiring procedures, or specialized requirements limit the candidate pool.
That makes it even more important to recognize transferable skills where the position allows them.
Someone with experience coordinating school operations may bring valuable skills to municipal administration.
A customer service professional may understand how to communicate with frustrated residents.
A project coordinator from another industry may already know how to manage deadlines, stakeholders, and competing priorities.
Of course, each candidate still needs to demonstrate that they can meet the job's actual requirements.
But refusing to consider someone because their previous title doesn't match the new one may eliminate a strong candidate before the conversation even begins.
Hiring Potential Requires Leadership Commitment
There's one important catch.
If an organization wants to hire people with transferable skills, it needs to be prepared to develop them.
You can't hire someone because they demonstrate learning potential and then provide no training, guidance, or support.
That's not an opportunity.
That's setting someone up to struggle.
A thoughtful onboarding process should explain expectations, introduce essential systems, establish early milestones, and provide regular feedback.
Supervisors should know what successful progress looks like.
Employees should know where to find help.
And both sides should understand which skills need to be developed.
Hiring for potential doesn't eliminate accountability.
It makes intentional development even more important.
Final Thought
A resume tells you where someone has been.
It doesn't tell you everything about where they can go.
Experience matters. Qualifications matter. Proven results matter.
But so do curiosity, adaptability, judgment, and the willingness to learn.
Organizations that recognize those qualities can expand their talent pool without abandoning reasonable hiring standards.
The goal isn't to hire someone who looks perfect on paper. It's to hire someone who can succeed in the role and continue growing as the organization changes.
So the next time a candidate doesn't check every box, ask yourself:
Is this a qualification they genuinely need before starting, or something the right person could learn?
That distinction might change who gets an interview.
And it might change who becomes your next great employee.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.