Portrait of a Graduate: Reimagining NYC's Educational Future
A few weeks before her graduation, a senior named Isabella stood in our packed auditorium at Richmond Hill High School, rehearsing her lines for a mock trial summation by day and polishing a lab report for her STEM research class by night. She was the first in her family to apply to college, and thanks to a combination of research opportunities, college partnerships that included AP courses, and counseling support, she headed off to a four-year university last September with a clear plan to study political science and public health. Isabella's story is not an exception at Richmond Hill High School in Queens, NY; it is the predictable result of thoughtfully coordinated systems and partnerships.
Intended Outcomes of the Portrait of a Graduate Model
As Principal of Richmond Hill High School, I am proud of the coordinated efforts my team makes every day to embrace the vision of a Portrait of a Graduate and to implement the best practices outlined in this article in ways that reflect the needs of our students and community. The "Portrait of a Graduate" model is designed to prepare students not just academically but as well-rounded individuals ready to tackle the challenges of the modern world. The intended outcome is to equip students with critical thinking skills, problem-solving abilities, and a robust set of soft skills, including communication and teamwork. This approach aims to create graduates who are not only college-ready but also career-ready and capable of contributing positively to their communities.
High Expectations with Real Support
High expectations only work when they are matched with deliberate, layered supports that are built into the life of the school, not added on as an afterthought. At Richmond Hill, this has meant pairing rigorous coursework with a non-negotiable intervention rhythm that includes after-school tutoring, Saturday classes, push-in supports, and targeted outreach to students and families when early warning signs- like course failures or chronic absence- begin to surface. By treating attendance and engagement as a shared responsibility, combining careful data monitoring with personal outreach and, when appropriate, incentives, the school has been able to focus on keeping students in class and on track rather than reacting after they have already fallen behind- an approach that other schools can adapt to their own schedules, staffing, and community needs.
Beyond Regents: A Richer Definition of Readiness
Current New York State graduation requirements focus heavily on credits and Regents examinations, which primarily measure content knowledge and test-taking performance. The “Portrait of a Graduate” model does not ignore content, but it redefines success to include the ability to apply knowledge to real problems, work in diverse teams, communicate across differences, and contribute to one’s community.
This represents a paradigm shift: from a narrow emphasis on seat time and scores to a richer, competency-based definition of readiness for college, career, and civic life. For schools already leaning into this work- through pathways, MTSS, extended-day partnerships, and student voice structures- the transition to a formal “Portrait” framework offers coherence and language for what they are already building. This approach could potentially lead to a more engaging and relevant educational experience for students, preparing them better for life after high school.
Community partnerships and extended learning
An essential ingredient is treating community partnerships as core infrastructure, not accessories. When schools co-design extended-day programming with community-based organizations- blending tutoring, enrichment, mentoring, mental health supports, and family engagement- the school day expands in both time and possibility.
These partners can also play a critical role in MTSS by helping deliver Tier 2 and Tier 3 supports after school, on weekends, or in flexible formats that families can access. Aligning partner work with academic goals, attendance, social-emotional learning, and postsecondary planning helps ensure that students’ needs are met in integrated, not fragmented, ways.
Equity, Subgroups, and New Measures of Success
The “Portrait of a Graduate” model holds particular promise for students who have not always been well served by traditional, test-heavy systems. Project-based assessments, performance tasks, internships, and community projects create multiple avenues for students to demonstrate mastery, reducing overreliance on single high-stakes exams. When students build and leverage skills through meaningful project-based assessments, they are not just demonstrating competency that could otherwise be reflected in spreadsheet data; they are collaborating with peers, honing communication and social and emotional skills, and building confidence that comes with making positive impacts. While these 'soft skills' may produce less quantifiable data, their downstream impact upon society is immeasurable.
For multilingual learners, students with disabilities, and students experiencing poverty, this approach- paired with MTSS- is even more empowering because it invites students to showcase their strengths in collaborative work, presentations, service learning, and applied problem-solving. It also foregrounds cultural competency and emotional intelligence, skills that are essential for navigating a diverse city and participating in civic life.
Compared with traditional graduation requirements that prioritize credits and standardized exams, this broader definition of readiness emphasizes applying knowledge, working in diverse teams, communicating across differences, and contributing meaningfully to one’s community. Schools that have begun this shift show how existing structures- credits, coursework, and assessments- can be complemented by richer, competency-based measures aligned with the “Portrait” vision.
Barriers to Implementation
Despite its benefits, the implementation of the "Portrait of a Graduate" model in NYC high schools faces several challenges. First, there is the issue of systemic change. Shifting from a well-established educational model to a relatively new and untested one requires significant adjustments in curriculum design, teaching methods, and assessment strategies. Additionally, teachers and administrators may require training to effectively adopt and support this new model.
Another barrier is the potential resistance from stakeholders who are accustomed to traditional metrics of academic success, such as standardized test scores and GPA. Convincing parents, universities, and even policymakers about the value of a holistic educational approach might be challenging, and inviting all stakeholders into the dialogue as collaborative thought-partners will be paramount to the success of this (or any) initiative that requires their support.
Resource allocation also poses a significant hurdle. Implementing a comprehensive model like "Portrait of a Graduate" often requires additional resources, such as new learning materials, technology, and possibly more staff. In a city as large as New York, securing the necessary funding and resources can be a daunting task. Schools can also explore creative or alternative funding sources, such as grant writing, strategic community partnerships, and existing supports, programs, and interns offered by nearby universities. When the 'will' is strong enough, there is always a 'way'.
A Shared Opportunity
Isabella's journey (she's currently thriving in her second semester) is one example of what becomes possible when a “Portrait of a Graduate” is used as a design blueprint rather than a slogan. At a time when New York City is reexamining its educational opportunities, this is a moment to align policy, resources, and school-level practice around a shared vision of what every graduate should know, be, and be able to do.
When teachers, staff, students, and families choose- day after day- to prioritize relationships, attendance, and meaningful learning experiences, they are doing more than improving a single school; they are investing in the children and future leaders that New York City, and communities like it, will rely on for years to come. The work is complex and often demanding, yet shared effort has shown that the investment pays off in the most meaningful way: in the confidence, agency, and success of our future leaders.
References
Battelle for Kids. “Portrait of a Graduate.” Battelle for Kids. Accessed January 17, 2026. https://www.battelleforkids.org/portrait-of-a-graduate/.
New York State Education Department. “Diploma Requirements.” New York State Education Department. Accessed January 17, 2026. https://www.nysed.gov/curriculum-instruction/diploma-requirements.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.