Culture Is Infrastructure: How Local Government Builds a Workforce That Can Handle the Next Decade

Picture this. It's a Tuesday morning at City Hall. A new hire walks in, badge still warm from the printer, coffee in hand, hopeful. She sits at a desk with no computer login, a binder from 2017, and a supervisor stuck in a budget meeting until noon. By Friday, she is quietly updating her LinkedIn. By month two, she is gone.
Now multiply that scene by thousands of desks across the country. Less than 7 percent of full-time civil service workers are under age 30, compared to 20 percent in the workforce overall, and roughly one in three government employees is eligible to retire this year, according to the National League of Cities and ICMA. The bench is thin, the stakes are high, and the old playbook of "post it and pray" is not going to save us.
Here is the good news. Cities that treat hiring and onboarding as one continuous experience, not two disconnected transactions, are pulling ahead. Research shows organizations with a strong onboarding process improve retention by 82 percent and productivity by more than 70 percent, according to a study cited by the SHRM Foundation and summarized by Devlin Peck. Whether you run a department of 500 or just landed your first supervisor role, the moves below are within reach.
Write the Job Post Like You Mean It
A job description is the front door of your agency. If the door is confusing, warped, or written in acronym soup, the best candidates keep walking. The MissionSquare Research Institute's 2025 workforce survey found that many governments are quietly winning the recruitment war by simply rewriting job narratives to be transparent about salary, benefits, and what a Tuesday actually looks like in the role.
Try this. Replace "responsible for stakeholder engagement across cross-functional teams" with "you will run our monthly community listening sessions and turn what residents say into action items the mayor's office actually reads." One version sounds like a compliance memo. The other sounds like a mission. Revisit descriptions at least once a year, because a role written for 2019 will not attract a 2026 hire.
While you are at it, widen the net. Post on public service job boards, yes, but also on LinkedIn, in Slack communities for civic technologists, on Spanish-language platforms, and at trade schools and HBCU career fairs. The candidate who will reinvent your permitting process may not be reading GovJobs.com on a Sunday night.
Interview Like a Scientist, Not a Talk Show Host
Here is a statistic that should be tattooed on every hiring manager's coffee mug. Structured interviews, where every candidate answers the same job-relevant questions and is scored against the same rubric, are the single strongest predictor of job performance, with a corrected validity of 0.42 versus just 0.19 for unstructured chats, according to the Sackett et al. 2022 meta-analysis reviewed in Cambridge's Industrial and Organizational Psychology journal. Google reports its own interviewers save roughly 40 minutes per interview using this method, and rejected candidates rate the experience 35 percent higher than those subjected to freewheeling conversations, as summarized by eSkill.
The recipe is not complicated. Pick four to six competencies that actually matter for the role. Write eight to twelve questions, mixing behavioral prompts ("tell me about a time you had to deliver bad news to a resident") with situational ones ("a council member calls you at 6 p.m. about a pothole video going viral, what do you do first"). Score each answer on a one to five scale with anchored examples. Then, and only then, open the floor for the candidate's questions and let the human warmth back in.
Panels help too, but only when they are diverse and trained. A homogeneous panel is just one bias with three faces. Bring in a frontline staff member, a peer from another department, and a community representative when appropriate. You will see the candidate from three angles instead of one.
Onboarding Starts Before the First Day
Twenty percent of employees quit within their first 45 days, per data compiled by Devlin Peck. Most of those quits are not about the work. They are about the silence between "you're hired" and "here's your desk."
Send a welcome email the day after the offer is signed. Include the org chart, a photo directory of the immediate team, and a short video from the department head explaining why the mission matters. Have IT set up the laptop and logins a week early. Assign a buddy, not just a supervisor. A buddy answers the questions people are too embarrassed to ask their boss, like where the good coffee is or how to actually submit a travel voucher.
On day one, spend the morning on mission, values, and how this specific role connects to the strategic plan. Bauer's foundational SHRM research on onboarding, still widely cited in 2025, calls this "role clarity plus social integration plus knowledge of culture and politics," and organizations that hit all four report dramatically higher one-year retention, per the SHRM Foundation summary. Skip the eight-hour PowerPoint marathon. Nobody remembers slide 47.
Make the First Year a Runway, Not a Cliff
Onboarding is not a week. It is a runway that should last at least 90 days, and the smartest agencies stretch it to a full year. Schedule 30, 60, and 90-day check-ins on the calendar the day the offer is accepted. Ask three questions every time. What is working? What is confusing? What would make you stay?
Feedback loops matter. The MGT public sector retention white paper notes that stay interviews, now used by 12 percent of public employers, are quietly becoming one of the most effective retention tools available, because they surface problems while there is still time to fix them. Exit interviews tell you why someone left. Stay interviews tell you why someone is thinking about it.
Pair check-ins with real skill-building. In-house training is offered by 72 percent of public sector organizations and leadership development by 58 percent, per the same report. If your agency has neither, that is your Monday morning to-do list. A new analyst who takes a data visualization course in month three becomes the person who redesigns the council dashboard in month nine.
Build a Culture People Do Not Want to Leave
The MissionSquare 2025 survey found that 60 percent of state and local governments now report success attracting new generations of workers, a genuine improvement, but the gains are concentrated in places that treat culture as infrastructure. Recognition programs, reported by 53 percent of organizations, are among the cheapest and most powerful retention tools. A handwritten note from the commissioner outperforms a $50 gift card almost every time.
Inclusion is not a poster in the break room. It is who is on the interview panel, whose ideas get airtime in the staff meeting, and whether the parent picking up a sick kid at 3 p.m. is treated the same as the person still at their desk at 7. Train supervisors on unconscious bias and cultural competency, and hold them accountable for the climate on their team, not just the outputs.
Promote from within whenever you honestly can. Nothing signals "there is a future here" louder than watching a coworker rise. Career ladders, job banding, and transparent succession planning are what turn a job into a career, and yet 61 percent of governments still report having no succession plan in place, according to the same MissionSquare data. That is not a talent problem. That is a leadership opportunity sitting in plain sight.
Keep the Machine Learning
The best hiring and onboarding systems are living organisms. They breathe. Applicant tracking systems can shave weeks off time-to-hire. Digital onboarding platforms can turn paperwork purgatory into a 20-minute mobile experience. But technology is a lever, not a strategy. Ask your last three hires and your last three departures what worked and what did not, then actually change something based on what they say.
Cities that treat every hire as a small experiment, measure the results honestly, and iterate quarterly are the ones building workforces that can handle whatever the next decade throws at them, from climate emergencies to AI adoption to the retirement wave already at the door.
Your Move
Public service is the most consequential work in America that most Americans never see. Every pothole filled, every kid fed, every permit approved, every 911 call answered, all of it depends on someone deciding to show up and stay. That someone is hired by you, welcomed by you, and either developed or lost by you.
So here is the challenge. Pick one thing from this article, just one, and change it before Friday. Rewrite a job post so it sounds like a human wrote it. Schedule the 30-day check-in you have been meaning to hold. Send a welcome email to someone starting Monday. The talent race is not won by the city with the biggest budget. It is won by the city whose people decide, on a Tuesday morning, that this is where they belong.
The badge is warm. The coffee is hot. What will she find when she sits down at your agency?
Bibliography
Bauer, Talya N. 2010. Onboarding New Employees: Maximizing Success. Alexandria, VA: SHRM Foundation. https://www.shrm.org.
Devlin Peck. 2025. "Employee Onboarding Statistics: Top Trends and Insights (2025)." January 3, 2025. https://www.devlinpeck.com/content/employee-onboarding-statistics.
eSkill. 2024. "How to Use Structured Interviews to Assess Candidates." Accessed July 19, 2026. https://www.eskill.com/resources/blog/how-to-use-structured-interviews.
International City/County Management Association. 2025. "Tackling the Local Government Talent Shortage." PM Magazine, November 1, 2025. https://icma.org/articles/pm-magazine/tackling-local-government-talent-shortage.
Levashina, Julia, Christopher J. Hartwell, Frederick P. Morgeson, and Michael A. Campion. 2014. "The Structured Employment Interview: Narrative and Quantitative Review of the Research Literature." Personnel Psychology 67 (1): 241 to 293.
MGT Consulting. 2025. Retaining Employees in the Public Sector. White paper, May 2025. https://www.mgt.us/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Public-Sector-Employee-Retention-White-Paper.pdf.
MissionSquare Research Institute. 2025. 2025 State and Local Government Workforce Survey Results. Washington, DC: MissionSquare Research Institute. https://research.missionsq.org/content/media/document/2025/5/2025_State_Local_Workforce_Report.pdf.
MissionSquare Research Institute. 2025. "MissionSquare Research Institute Identifies Six Public Service Workforce Trends to Watch in 2025." January 15, 2025. https://www.missionsq.org/about-us/news-and-updates/media-inquiries/news-20250115-msri6publicserviceworkforcetrends.html.
National League of Cities. 2025. "Understanding the Challenges Facing the Municipal Workforce." December 13, 2025. https://www.nlc.org/article/2025/12/13/understanding-the-challenges-facing-the-municipal-workforce/.
Sackett, Paul R., Charlene Zhang, Christopher M. Berry, and Filip Lievens. 2023. "Revisiting the Design of Selection Systems in Light of New Findings Regarding the Validity of Widely Used Predictors." Industrial and Organizational Psychology 16 (3): 283 to 300. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/industrial-and-organizational-psychology/article/structured-interviews-moving-beyond-mean-validity/7CB1F7C86CB0D15328B3F07AD5F964E2.
Society for Human Resource Management. 2024. "Talent Acquisition Resources." Accessed July 19, 2026. https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/topics/talent-acquisition.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.