Bridging the Civil-Military Divide Inside the VA

Bridging the Civil-Military Divide Inside the VA
The most effective VA teams I have seen are those composed of both veterans and civilians who can communicate across the civil-military divide. Veterans bring firsthand knowledge of military culture, command structures, and the unique stressors of service. Civilians often bring specialized expertise in health care administration, policy, and data analytics. When these strengths are combined and respected, the result is a more responsive and effective institution. However, this collaboration requires intentional leadership that values both perspectives without allowing either to dominate.
One persistent challenge is the difference in expectations. Veterans are used to a chain of command where decisions are made quickly and orders are executed without delay. The VA, like many federal agencies, operates within a bureaucracy that often slows down decision making. This friction can be frustrating for both sides. Leaders must actively facilitate communication, ensuring that veterans working in or interacting with the VA understand the constraints under which the agency operates, while also advocating internally for process improvements that reduce unnecessary red tape. The Veterans Health Administration’s efforts to streamline hiring processes, for example, came from acknowledging that the traditional HR system did not meet the urgency of veteran care needs (GAO 2023)1.
The Role of Veteran Identity in Service Delivery
Veteran identity is not just a demographic box to check - it informs how we perceive trust, authority, and support. When veterans interact with someone who has also worn the uniform, there is often a sense of immediate credibility. This dynamic can be powerful in service delivery, particularly in mental health, benefits counseling, and case management. Peer support programs have shown marked success in improving outcomes for veterans by leveraging this shared identity. A 2022 VA study found that veterans paired with peer specialists were more likely to remain engaged in care and report satisfaction with services (U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs 2022)2.
However, relying solely on shared identity without proper training can be problematic. Not all veterans have the same experiences, and assuming a homogenous veteran perspective risks alienating those whose service was different, complicated, or traumatic. Peer specialists and veteran staff must be trained not just in technical competencies but also in cultural humility and trauma-informed care. This approach helps mitigate the potential for re-traumatization and builds a more inclusive system that supports veterans across the full spectrum of experiences.
Operational Accountability and Mission Drift
One of the hardest challenges inside the VA is maintaining operational accountability while avoiding mission drift. The original mission of the VA was to care for those “who shall have borne the battle” - a clear, targeted mandate. Over time, as needs have diversified and expectations have grown, the VA has been asked to do more with the same or fewer resources. This can dilute focus and leave employees unclear on priorities. For those of us who served, mission clarity is not a luxury - it is a necessity. When the mission is unclear, performance suffers and morale drops.
Practical steps to mitigate mission drift include setting clear performance metrics tied to veteran outcomes, not just internal process milestones. For example, instead of measuring the number of claims processed, evaluate the accuracy and timeliness of those claims and the satisfaction of the veterans receiving them. The VA’s modernization efforts have begun incorporating outcome-based metrics, such as those tracked by the Veterans Experience Office, but implementation remains uneven across regions (VA OIG 2023)3. Municipal practitioners can learn from this by applying similar outcome-based accountability systems in local veteran support programs.
Systemic Change Requires Tactical Leadership
Veterans often excel at tactical leadership - solving problems on the ground, adjusting to changing conditions, and keeping teams focused. However, systemic change requires a different kind of leadership: one that can navigate policy, politics, and entrenched institutional interests. Veterans in leadership roles at the VA must learn to operate across both spheres. This means building coalitions, communicating effectively with Congress, and understanding the nuances of federal procurement and budgeting processes. The VA’s recent rollout of the Electronic Health Record Modernization (EHRM) program illustrates how technical upgrades require strategic leadership to avoid costly setbacks (GAO 2023)4.
Leadership development programs specifically designed for veterans transitioning into federal service can be a key lever for change. These programs should include mentoring, cross-sector exposure, and training in public policy analysis and implementation. The VA Talent Management System and DoD SkillBridge programs are examples of platforms that can be expanded or adapted to support these goals. For municipal governments, partnering with veteran service organizations to create local leadership pipelines can bridge the gap between federal initiatives and community-level execution.
Building Trust Through Transparency and Follow-Through
Veterans are often skeptical of institutions, particularly when promises are made but not kept. This skepticism is compounded by experiences with delayed claims, canceled appointments, or inconsistent information. Building trust requires not just empathy but consistency, transparency, and follow-through. One of the most effective practices I’ve seen is the use of real-time communication tools that allow veterans to track the status of their claims or appointments, similar to tracking a package. These tools reduce anxiety and increase trust by showing that the agency is working on their behalf.
Transparency also involves owning mistakes. When the VA publicly discloses where it fell short and what steps it is taking to correct the issue, it signals respect for the veteran community. The publication of facility-level performance data and wait times, while sometimes uncomfortable, has pushed institutions to improve and allowed veterans to make informed choices about their care (VA Access to Care 2023)5. Municipal leaders can adopt similar practices by publishing performance dashboards for local veteran services and inviting feedback from the populations they serve.
Conclusion: A Call to Serve with Purpose
Working inside the VA as a veteran has reinforced my belief that those who have served are uniquely positioned to lead change for those still navigating the system. But shared experience is only the starting point. Real impact comes from combining that experience with training, accountability, and a relentless focus on outcomes. Whether at the federal or municipal level, public servants must remember that veterans are not a monolith. They are individuals with diverse needs, strengths, and challenges.
The path forward requires aligning operations with mission, investing in leadership development, and holding institutions accountable through transparent performance metrics. Only then can we deliver the kind of service that honors the commitment veterans made when they raised their right hand. And for those of us who once wore the uniform, the mission continues - not on the battlefield, but in the offices, clinics, and policy rooms where we now serve.
Bibliography
U.S. Government Accountability Office. "VA Health Care: Assessing VA's Efforts to Improve Staffing and Hiring." GAO-23-105238. March 2023. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-105238.
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. "Peer Support Services: Annual Program Evaluation Report." Office of Mental Health and Suicide Prevention. 2022. https://www.mentalhealth.va.gov/peer_support.asp.
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Office of Inspector General. "Veterans Experience Office: Implementation of Customer Experience Data." Report No. 22-00123-56. March 2023. https://www.va.gov/oig/pubs/VAOIG-22-00123-56.pdf.
U.S. Government Accountability Office. "Electronic Health Records: VA Needs to Address Organizational Weaknesses." GAO-23-105765. September 2023. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-105765.
VA Access to Care. "Facility-Level Performance Data." U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Accessed March 2024. https://www.accesstocare.va.gov/.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.