What Brooklyn Taught Me About Economic Development

My first bona fide full-time job in New York City government was working for Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz.
I was 23 years old.
At the time, I understood that Brooklyn was changing. I don't think I remotely understood how much.
More than two decades later, I can walk through Downtown Brooklyn and barely recognize the skyline. Neighborhoods that were already desirable have become destinations for another generation of New Yorkers. Park Slope, in particular, has become an “it” neighborhood for young families. Brooklyn has a major professional sports team again. Entire corridors have been transformed by housing, retail, cultural institutions and private investment.
No mayor, borough president, developer or government program created modern Brooklyn by itself. The Bloomberg administration's 2004 Downtown Brooklyn rezoning, private investment, demographic changes and broader economic forces all played important roles. A later State assessment found that Downtown Brooklyn added more than 14,000 housing units following the rezoning and related investments.
But working for Marty gave me my first close-up view of something I have thought about ever since:
Economic development works best when public dollars do more than purchase something. They should help create the conditions for additional economic and community activity.
Marty Understood That People Develop Places Too
Marty was perhaps Brooklyn's greatest cheerleader.
That description sometimes understates what he was doing.
His famous summer concert series brought residents together for free performances and helped create communal experiences around Brooklyn. His Seaside Summer Concert Series in Coney Island and Martin Luther King Jr. Concert Series in Central Brooklyn attracted major performers and large crowds over many years.
That may sound more like entertainment than economic development.
I see it differently now.
People don't choose communities solely because of tax rates, zoning or square footage.
They choose places because they want to be there.
Culture matters. Parks matter. Restaurants matter. Institutions matter. Shared experiences matter.
Marty understood the value of making Brooklyn feel like a destination rather than somewhere people had to leave to experience New York City.
And there was another, less visible part of the job that influenced me.
Sometimes Government's Job Is to Supply the First Dollar
Borough presidents can allocate portions of the City's capital budget to eligible projects at schools, cultural organizations, community facilities and nonprofit institutions. That remains part of the Brooklyn Borough President's budget role today.
As a young government employee, I saw how public capital could help get projects moving.
The amounts didn't always have to be enormous.
A nonprofit might need to improve a facility. A cultural institution might need equipment. A community organization might have an idea but lack enough capital to turn it into a physical project.
A relatively targeted City investment could become part of something larger.
That was an important lesson for me:
Sometimes economic development isn't government supplying every dollar. It is government supplying the dollar that helps unlock the next one.
That principle should also require accountability. Public investment should have a public purpose, and government should be willing to examine whether promised benefits actually materialize.
But the concept is powerful.
Then Brooklyn Thought Much Bigger
Atlantic Yards represented economic development at an entirely different scale.
Marty was an enthusiastic supporter of Forest City Ratner's proposed project and the effort to bring the Nets to Brooklyn.
The project became controversial, took much longer than originally envisioned and developed differently from the initial vision. Those facts are part of its history.
But one very visible piece became reality.
Barclays Center opened in 2012, and the Nets moved from New Jersey to Brooklyn for the 2012-13 season.
For the first time since the Dodgers left after the 1957 season, Brooklyn had a major-league professional sports team calling the borough home.
Think about that transformation.
I started working in Brooklyn government in 2004.
Less than a decade later, there was an NBA arena near Atlantic and Flatbush.
Two decades later, the skyline around Downtown Brooklyn bears little resemblance to what I remember when I started.
Government didn't create all of that.
Government helped establish conditions in which enormous amounts of private activity could occur.
That distinction has shaped how I think about economic development today.
Twenty Years Later, I See the Same Opportunity in Procurement
My career eventually took me away from Borough Hall and into budgeting, capital planning, technology and procurement.
Today, I look at economic development from the purchasing side of government.
And I increasingly believe New York City is underusing one of its most powerful economic-development tools:
its own purchasing power.
Every year, government buys tremendous quantities of goods and services.
Every purchase creates economic activity somewhere.
The question I think we should ask more often is:
Where?
If New York City spends a dollar with a local business, some portion of that money can circulate again within the local economy through wages, rent, purchases and taxes.
That does not mean taxpayers should write blank checks to local companies.
Competition still matters.
Price still matters.
Quality still matters.
But geography has economic value too.
I Would Make M/WBE Rules Both More Generous and More Demanding
The same principle applies to minority- and women-owned business programs.
I support the objective behind M/WBE programs: government purchasing should be accessible to businesses that historically have not received an equitable opportunity to participate.
But I would make the system simultaneously more favorable and stricter.
NYC rules already recognize the concept of a commercially useful function—whether a firm is genuinely performing, managing or supervising meaningful contract work rather than serving principally as a pass-through.
I would enforce that principle aggressively.
If an M/WBE receives the economic benefit associated with M/WBE participation, I want that business actually building capacity.
Employing people.
Managing work.
Developing expertise.
Building references.
Providing services.
Growing.
The objective shouldn't be moving an invoice through a certified company.
The objective should be creating stronger companies.
And in exchange for demanding genuine participation, I would be willing to provide substantially greater procurement advantages.
What If NYC Rewarded Ownership, Geography and Actual Work?
I would like New York to explore a cumulative procurement preference structured approximately like this:
A qualifying New York State business could receive a 5% evaluation preference.
A New York City business could receive another 5%.
Certified M/WBE status could provide another 5%.
And an M/WBE performing meaningful work itself—not merely serving as an intermediary—could potentially receive an additional 5%.
That could create as much as a 20% evaluation preference for a qualifying NYC-based M/WBE actually performing substantive work.
That doesn't necessarily mean government writes a check for 20% more. Bid preferences can instead adjust how competing offers are evaluated.
There are precedents worth studying.
San Francisco's Local Business Enterprise program provides qualifying small and micro local businesses a 10% bid discount on many procurements below $10 million, includes additional geographically targeted preferences in some circumstances, and incorporates a commercially useful function requirement.
New York law, however, presents a significant obstacle. A State Comptroller legal opinion interpreting General Municipal Law §103 concluded that municipalities generally cannot simply create a local-vendor price preference where State competitive-bidding law requires award to the lowest responsible bidder.
So Albany would likely have to authorize a broader program.
I think that conversation is worth having.
Public Authorities Show What Scale Can Accomplish
New York already understands that government can shape economic development through institutions operating at enormous scale.
The New York Power Authority operates more than 1,550 circuit-miles of transmission and owns or operates roughly one-third of New York's transmission backbone. Reliable, scalable power infrastructure is itself a prerequisite for economic development.
Empire State Development uses another approach. New York's film-production tax credit provides qualifying productions a 30% credit, with the program currently funded at $700 million annually through 2036.
Then there is perhaps New York City's most important economic-development machine of all:
The subway.
The MTA allows millions of people to connect with employment, education, entertainment and commerce. Transit effectively enlarges the labor market because people do not have to live next door to where they work.
But the MTA also illustrates the other side of public investment.
It isn't enough to spend public money. We have to care how much output each dollar buys.
NYU's Transit Costs Project found that the first phase of the Second Avenue Subway was the world's most expensive subway project per kilometer in its international database, at roughly eight to twelve times its composite baseline.
Labor costs and work practices are part of that problem, but the research points to a broader combination that includes oversized stations, procurement, design decisions, soft costs and institutional practices—not prevailing wages alone.
That distinction is important.
The subway may be one of the greatest economic-development investments New York ever made.
But if constructing each additional mile costs several times what comparable cities spend, eventually extraordinary costs prevent us from building the infrastructure that would generate the next round of economic development.
Cost control is economic-development policy too.
The Lesson I Learned in Brooklyn
Looking back, I think Marty Markowitz taught me something at 23 that took me another twenty years to fully appreciate.
Economic development isn't one thing.
Sometimes it is a concert.
Sometimes it is $100,000 toward a nonprofit capital project.
Sometimes it is an arena.
Sometimes it is a subway extension.
Sometimes it is electrical infrastructure.
Sometimes it is a tax credit.
And sometimes it is a purchase order awarded to a business that gets its first meaningful opportunity to work for New York City.
The common denominator should be multiplication.
What happens after the public dollar is spent?
Does it unlock additional investment?
Does it create infrastructure?
Does it strengthen an institution?
Does it create a job?
Does it build a business?
Does it create competition?
Does it make a neighborhood somewhere people want to live?
Does it make another dollar of economic activity possible?
Or did we simply spend it?
More than twenty years after I first walked into Brooklyn Borough Hall, I can look at Brooklyn's skyline and see how dramatically a place can change within one professional lifetime.
Some of that transformation came from government.
Much more came from people, businesses and private investment responding to changing conditions and opportunities.
I think that is government's most productive economic-development role.
Don't try to create the entire economy. Create the conditions in which people can build it.
And when government does spend public money, structure that spending so the benefits don't stop with the first recipient.
The best public dollar is one that keeps working after government spends it.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.