The Psychology of Messaging: Why Some Campaigns Go Viral and Others Don’t

The Psychology of Messaging: Why Some Campaigns Go Viral and Others Don’t
One of the strongest psychological triggers in messaging is emotion. Studies have consistently shown that emotionally charged content is more likely to be shared across platforms. When people feel something deeply—whether it's joy, anger, surprise, or empathy—they are more inclined to pass that feeling along to others. This behavior is rooted in our social instincts; sharing emotional content helps us connect with others and validate our own responses. Research from the University of Pennsylvania found that content evoking high-arousal emotions, such as awe or anger, was significantly more likely to go viral than content that evoked low-arousal emotions like sadness or contentment1.
Municipal campaigns can leverage this by focusing on stories that highlight personal impact. For example, a city initiative to improve park safety might feature a parent's testimonial about how their child can now play safely in the neighborhood park. This type of message goes beyond facts and speaks to the audience's values and experiences. Emotional resonance helps move the message from passive consumption to active engagement, increasing the likelihood of shares, likes, and community support.
Relatability: Speaking the Audience’s Language
A message resonates when the audience sees themselves in it. Relatability is critical in crafting effective messaging, especially in municipal communications where trust and familiarity influence public response. Campaigns that use language, imagery, and scenarios drawn from the target community tend to perform better. This is because people are more responsive to messages that reflect their lived experiences and personal concerns. According to research published in the Journal of Marketing Research, people are more likely to engage with content that aligns with their identity and community values2.
For municipal communicators, this means tailoring messages to the specific needs and cultural context of the community. A recycling campaign in a coastal town might focus on protecting marine life, while the same campaign in a desert city might highlight water conservation. Using local vernacular, familiar landmarks, and resident testimonials enhances relatability. When people feel seen and understood, they are more likely to trust the message and act on it.
Storytelling: The Structure That Sticks
Stories are more memorable than standalone facts. Neuroscience research indicates that narratives activate more areas of the brain than data alone, making them more likely to be remembered and retold3. A strong story has a clear structure: a character with a goal, a challenge, and a resolution. This structure mirrors the way people naturally process events in their own lives. When a campaign presents a story people can follow and emotionally invest in, it becomes easier for them to internalize the message.
One effective municipal example was a campaign by the City of Portland, Oregon, promoting pedestrian safety. Rather than lead with statistics, the campaign followed a young girl’s daily walk to school, highlighting both her challenges and the city's infrastructure improvements. The narrative allowed residents to connect emotionally while absorbing practical information. Stories like this turn abstract policies into personal experiences that are easier to understand and more compelling to act upon.
Visual and Platform Optimization: The Role of Format
A message’s success is not only determined by its content but also by how and where it is delivered. The same message can perform poorly on one platform and excel on another due to differences in audience behavior, content format, and timing. The rise of mobile-first consumption means that visual elements—photos, short videos, infographics—often outperform text-heavy messages. According to the Pew Research Center, over 85% of adults in the United States now access news and information via smartphones, making visual clarity and brevity essential4.
Municipal communicators should adapt messages to fit platform-specific norms. A detailed policy update might be appropriate on a city website or in an email newsletter, but a 30-second video clip or animated graphic might be more effective on Instagram or TikTok. Testing different formats and tracking engagement metrics helps refine future messaging strategies. This ensures the message not only reaches the intended audience but also resonates in a format they are most likely to interact with.
Social Proof and Peer Influence
Another key psychological factor is social proof—the idea that people are more likely to engage with something if they see others doing it first. This principle is especially powerful on social media, where likes, shares, and comments serve as visible endorsements. When a message gains early traction, it creates a bandwagon effect that can drive exponential growth in reach and engagement. This is why initial seeding with trusted community voices can be so effective. A well-known neighborhood leader sharing a city message can spark broader community participation.
Municipal campaigns can use this strategy by encouraging community endorsements and user-generated content. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, many cities asked residents to post photos of themselves wearing masks with a designated hashtag. These posts created a sense of community participation and helped normalize the behavior. When residents see their peers engaging with a message, they are more likely to follow suit, especially if the behavior aligns with shared values or public expectations5.
Practical Steps for Municipal Communicators
Based on the psychological principles discussed, there are several actionable steps municipal communicators can take to improve the effectiveness of their messaging. Start by identifying the core emotion you want to evoke—whether it's pride, concern, hope, or gratitude. Design the message around that emotional trigger using real-life stories and visuals. Choose your messenger carefully; community members are more influential than faceless institutions when it comes to building trust and engagement.
Next, adapt the message to fit the platform. For each campaign, create multiple content versions optimized for different channels. A short video clip might work well on social media, while a longer article or policy brief can live on the city's website. Use analytics to track engagement and refine your approach. Finally, build in mechanisms for social proof. Encourage early adopters to share the message, and spotlight community members who are embodying the campaign’s goals. These tactics, grounded in psychology and supported by data, will help ensure your message doesn't just reach your audience—it moves them to action.
Bibliography
Berger, Jonah, and Katherine L. Milkman. "What Makes Online Content Go Viral?" Journal of Marketing Research 49, no. 2 (2012): 192–205.
Escalas, Jennifer Edson. "Narrative Processing: Building Consumer Connections to Brands." Journal of Consumer Psychology 14, no. 1-2 (2004): 168-180.
Zak, Paul J. "Why Inspired Leaders Don’t Always Need a Business Case." Harvard Business Review, July 2015. https://hbr.org/2015/07/why-inspired-leaders-dont-always-need-a-business-case.
Pew Research Center. "Mobile Fact Sheet." April 2021. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/mobile/.
Cialdini, Robert B. Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. Revised edition. New York: Harper Business, 2006.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.