Inclusivity in Action: How Municipalities Can Hire for True Leadership Potential

The traditional hiring model often leans too heavily on formal credentials, sidelining those who have built their competence through alternative routes. Leadership today requires recognizing that capability is not only validated by certificates or degrees but also by accomplishments, adaptability, and the ability to lead teams through real challenges. While formal education can signal foundational knowledge, it does not always capture the full depth of a person's leadership capacity. Leaders must be willing to question filters that eliminate candidates based on arbitrary criteria rather than actual performance or promise.
Municipal governments in particular could benefit from adopting more inclusive recruitment approaches. For instance, skills-based hiring practices, which focus on demonstrable abilities and prior outcomes, can open doors to a broader range of qualified applicants. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management has encouraged federal agencies to expand the use of skills-based assessments for this reason, emphasizing that experience and competencies often better predict job performance than degrees alone1. Municipal hiring managers can apply this insight by reassessing job postings, removing unnecessary degree requirements, and incorporating structured interviews and practical assessments that evaluate candidates’ real-world problem-solving abilities.
The Value of Lived Experience in Leadership
Lived experience - the lessons shaped by navigating hardship, uncertainty, and complexity - often cultivates a leadership style rooted in empathy, resilience, and practical know-how. These qualities are particularly valuable in public service, where leaders must navigate competing priorities, limited resources, and diverse community needs. Leaders who have advanced through nontraditional paths often bring a deeper sensitivity to the barriers facing others and a strong commitment to inclusive decision-making. These attributes cannot be taught in a classroom but are often hard-won through experience.
For example, leaders with backgrounds in community organizing, military service, or trade work may bring crucial insights into how policies impact people on the ground. These perspectives can enrich strategic planning and promote more equitable outcomes. Research supports the idea that diverse leadership teams, including those with varied educational and experiential backgrounds, tend to make better decisions and foster more innovation2. Encouraging diverse pathways into leadership roles strengthens not only team dynamics but also public trust in institutions.
Reframing What It Means to Be “Qualified”
Leadership today requires a fresh lens on qualifications. Instead of asking whether a candidate has a specific degree, we should be asking whether they’ve led through ambiguity, inspired others in difficult circumstances, or delivered results without ideal conditions. These are the markers of leadership readiness. As the private sector moves toward credential transparency and alternative pathways, municipalities should not lag behind. Cities like San Francisco and New York have already started pilot programs to expand access to government roles through apprenticeships and community-based hiring initiatives3.
A practical step for leadership teams is to conduct a qualifications audit across job descriptions. Evaluate whether each requirement is truly essential to job performance or simply a legacy from past hiring norms. Consider substituting experience equivalents for degree requirements, such as “5 years of progressive leadership experience in a related field.” This allows individuals who have built their expertise outside of formal academic settings to compete on a level playing field. Revising how we define “qualified” helps unlock a broader talent pool and aligns hiring with the actual demands of the role.
Developing Leadership from Within
Another key perspective in leadership development is the importance of nurturing internal talent. Many organizations overlook their current staff when filling leadership roles, opting instead for external candidates with traditional credentials. However, investing in leadership development programs for frontline employees can yield strong long-term returns. Programs like rotational assignments, mentorship cohorts, and internal fellowships allow employees to gain exposure to strategic decision-making and build cross-functional skills. These initiatives help identify and prepare high-potential staff who may not yet have formal titles but demonstrate leadership behaviors daily.
The International City/County Management Association (ICMA) emphasizes the value of succession planning and leadership pipelines at all levels of local government4. By creating structured opportunities for growth, agencies can retain institutional knowledge, improve morale, and promote equity in advancement. Leaders should work with human resource departments to map out career pathways that reflect both organizational needs and employee aspirations. Recognizing and cultivating leadership potential from within sends a powerful signal that development is valued and that diverse paths to leadership are both possible and encouraged.
Actionable Steps for Leaders to Expand Perspectives
Leaders committed to expanding their perspective must begin by examining their own assumptions. Ask: What biases might be influencing how I assess leadership potential? Am I valuing polish over substance? Am I overlooking people because their resumes don't look like mine did? These self-assessments are critical for building more inclusive and effective teams. Peer coaching, reverse mentoring, and leadership retreats that focus on equity and inclusion can help foster this kind of reflective growth.
From a policy standpoint, leaders can champion updates to hiring guidelines, ensure interview panels are diverse, and advocate for training programs that equip hiring managers to recognize nontraditional talent. They can also lead by example, sharing their own stories of unconventional paths and highlighting team members who have advanced without typical credentials. When leaders model openness to different experiences, it encourages a culture shift throughout the organization. It signals that leadership is about impact, not pedigree.
Conclusion: Leadership Is a Practice, Not a Position
Leadership is not defined by titles or diplomas, but by action, influence, and integrity. The most effective leaders are those who recognize talent in unexpected places, elevate others, and challenge outdated norms. When hiring and development practices reflect these values, organizations become more agile, inclusive, and capable of meeting today’s complex challenges. Reframing leadership to include lived experience, grit, and curiosity is not lowering standards. It's raising them to meet the realities of the work and the communities we serve.
By shifting how we identify and support leadership potential, especially in municipal government, we lay the groundwork for more dynamic, responsive institutions. Building teams that reflect the full spectrum of experience in our communities requires intention, but the payoff is clear: stronger decisions, deeper trust, and a public workforce that truly represents those it serves.
Bibliography
U.S. Office of Personnel Management. “Skills-Based Hiring and Assessment.” Accessed April 15, 2024. https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/hiring-information/skills-based-hiring/.
Hunt, Vivian, Dennis Layton, and Sara Prince. “Why Diversity Matters.” McKinsey & Company, January 2015. https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/why-diversity-matters.
Partnership for Public Service. “Opportunity Knock$: Opening Pathways into Government.” 2023. https://ourpublicservice.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Opportunity-Knocks-Opening-Pathways-into-Government.pdf.
International City/County Management Association (ICMA). “Succession Planning in Local Government.” 2022. https://icma.org/succession-planning-local-government.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.