The COVID EIDL Problem Is Much Bigger Than Our Small Business

Recently, I wrote about our small business’s experience with a COVID Economic Injury Disaster Loan. I explained how we borrowed money during one of the most uncertain economic periods of our lifetimes, how interest began accumulating before our first payment was due, and how- after years of faithfully making payments- we still owe more than we originally borrowed.
After writing that article, I started wondering about something. How many other small businesses are in the same situation? So I started looking at the numbers. What I discovered made our individual experience seem like one very small part of an extraordinarily large story.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, approximately four million small businesses and nonprofit organizations received Economic Injury Disaster Loans from the U.S. Small Business Administration. Altogether, the federal government lent nearly $390 billion through the COVID EIDL program. Think about that number for a moment. $390 billion.
These weren’t primarily grants. They were loans. And behind those loans were millions of small businesses; restaurants, contractors, family-owned stores, consultants, manufacturers, service businesses and countless other enterprises, that were trying to survive an economic catastrophe they didn’t create.
For many of us, the EIDL program did exactly what it was intended to do. It helped us survive. But surviving the pandemic and surviving the loan may turn out to be two different things. Our experience raises a question that I believe deserves much more attention:
What has happened to those four million borrowers? How many are still making payments? How many owe as much as, or more than, they originally borrowed? How much of their monthly payment is going toward interest rather than principal?
How many have needed hardship accommodations? How many have become delinquent? How many loans have already been charged off? And perhaps most importantly: How many otherwise viable small businesses are now carrying COVID-era federal debt that could remain with them for decades?
This isn’t simply a story about borrowers who don’t want to repay money they borrowed. Most small-business owners I know understand what a loan is. We signed documents. We accepted the money. We have an obligation to repay it. But there is another side to this story.
The federal government encouraged small businesses to use EIDL loans as an economic lifeline during an unprecedented national emergency. Businesses were closed or restricted through no fault of their own. Revenue disappeared almost overnight. Owners were trying to save employees’ jobs, keep paying rent and utilities, and prevent businesses they had spent lifetimes building from disappearing.
The government offered them a bridge.Now we need to ask whether, for some businesses, that bridge has become an anchor. Our business is only one of millions. That is why I believe Congress, the SBA, small-business organizations, economists and journalists need to take another serious look at the long-term consequences of the COVID EIDL program.
We should know how much principal remains outstanding. We should know how much interest has accumulated. We should know how many businesses are delinquent or in hardship programs. And we should understand what these loans are doing to the smallest businesses in America. Because $390 billion isn’t merely a number on a government spreadsheet.
Behind every one of those loans is, or was, a business. Behind many of those businesses is a family. And behind those families are employees, customers and communities that depend upon small businesses continuing to survive. COVID may be behind us. The economic injury may not be.






Join the discussion
Members can read and add comments on every article.